How to look back on a decision without fooling yourself.

Judge the call by what you knew when you made it, not only by how it turned out. The only reliable way to know what you knew is to have written it down at the time. Then look back once, against that record, and ask two separate questions: was it a reasonable call, and would you carry on now?
Outcomes rewrite the decision
People judge the quality of a decision by its outcome, even when they know the outcome was luck (Baron & Hershey, 1988, repeated). Once they know how things turned out, they believe they saw it coming (Guilbault et al., 2004, a meta-analysis). They remember their reasons as more in favour of what they chose than they were (Mather, Shafir & Johnson, 2000). In one experiment people defended choices they had never made, after a switch they didn’t notice (Johansson et al., 2005).
None of this is carelessness. Memory edits itself toward a story that makes sense. Which is why a review done from memory mostly reviews the story.
Warnings aren’t enough
Telling people to ignore what they now know barely reduces hindsight (Pohl & Hell, 1996, one study). What helps is asking what else could have happened (Arkes et al., 1988). Better still is reading what you actually wrote at the time: the options, your lean, how you felt and why you chose.
Ask two questions, not one
“Would you make that call again?” mixes two things that feel different and are regretted differently: the process and the outcome (Connolly & Zeelenberg, 2002). Ask them separately. First: given what you knew, was it a reasonable call? Then: knowing what you know now, would you carry on?
Your part, asked kindly
Asking “what part did I play?” is useful, and people do tend to credit themselves for successes and blame circumstances for failures (Mezulis et al., 2004, a meta-analysis). But that pattern shrinks in people who are low or hard on themselves, and they may over-blame instead. So allow “it was out of my hands” as an answer, start from a little kindness, and end with one thing you would do differently next time (Epstude & Roese, 2008, a review). After a good outcome, ask how much was luck.
When to look back
Look when the outcome has had time to show, and only once. Early doubts after a big change are common, and they are about the adjustment more than the call (Richardson & Gilovich, 2023). Looking again and again undoes the settling that closing the decision gave you.
More questions
It turned out badly. Was it a bad decision?
Not necessarily. Outcomes depend on luck as well as judgement. Check what you wrote at the time and ask whether, given what you knew, it was a reasonable call.
Sources
- Baron J, Hershey JC (1988). Outcome bias in decision evaluation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54(4).
- Guilbault RL et al. (2004). A meta-analysis of research on hindsight bias. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 26(2–3).
- Mather M, Shafir E, Johnson MK (2000). Misremembrance of options past. Psychological Science 11(2).
- Johansson P et al. (2005). Failure to detect mismatches between intention and outcome. Science 310.
- Pohl RF, Hell W (1996). No reduction in hindsight bias after complete information and repeated testing. OBHDP 67(1).
- Arkes HR et al. (1988). Eliminating the hindsight bias. Journal of Applied Psychology 73(2).
- Connolly T, Zeelenberg M (2002). Regret in decision making. Current Directions in Psychological Science 11(6).
- Mezulis AH et al. (2004). Is there a universal positivity bias in attributions? Psychological Bulletin 130(5).
- Epstude K, Roese NJ (2008). The functional theory of counterfactual thinking. Personality and Social Psychology Review 12(2).
- Richardson E, Gilovich T (2023). The temporal pattern of regret, a partial replication. Royal Society Open Science 10(6).