What should you ask yourself before a big decision?
Four with good evidence behind them: What would I tell a friend? Will this feel as big a year from now? Could I explain it to someone I respect? What else will be going on a month after this? Pick one or two. Asking many questions at once tends to backfire.
Why these four
What would I tell a friend? People reason more wisely about others’ problems than their own (Grossmann & Kross, 2014).
Will this feel as big a year from now? People overestimate how long their feelings will last (Gilbert et al., 1998, repeated). Imagining the distance eases distress (Bruehlman-Senecal & Ayduk, 2015, one lab).
Could I explain it to someone I respect? Expecting to account for a choice makes people think it through more carefully (Lerner & Tetlock, 1999, a review).
What else will be going on a month after this? People tend to picture one event in isolation and forget the rest of life that will surround it (Wilson et al., 2000, one lab).
One or two, not all of them
More is not better. Asked for a long list of counterarguments, people became more biased, not less (Sanna, Schwarz & Stocker, 2002). Choose the question that fits the feeling you have about the decision, answer it in a line, and decide.
Sources
- Grossmann I, Kross E (2014). Psychological Science 25(8).
- Gilbert DT et al. (1998). Immune neglect. JPSP 75(3).
- Bruehlman-Senecal E, Ayduk O (2015). This too shall pass. JPSP 108(2).
- Lerner JS, Tetlock PE (1999). Accounting for the effects of accountability. Psychological Bulletin 125(2).
- Wilson TD et al. (2000). Focalism. JPSP 78(5).
- Sanna LJ, Schwarz N, Stocker SL (2002). When debiasing backfires. JEP: LMC 28(3).