How do you stop overthinking a decision?
Give it a time, and change the kind of thinking. Abstract “why” questions keep you circling; concrete “how, what, when” questions move you forward. Until the time you set, write down only what you learn, one line at a time. At the time, choose.
With no time set
With a time to decide
Why overthinking keeps going
Going over a decision in the abstract lowers your willingness to commit (Ward et al., 2003), and putting it off brings short-term relief, which makes it easy to repeat (Anderson, 2003).
What helps
Concrete questions: how would the first week go, what would I need to know, when will I find out (Watkins, 2008). A little distance: writing about it as if it were a friend’s problem (Grossmann & Kross, 2014). And an end: a set time, after which the question is closed unless something actually changes.
Sources
- Ward A et al. (2003). Can’t quite commit. PSPB 29(1).
- Anderson CJ (2003). The psychology of doing nothing. Psychological Bulletin 129(1).
- Watkins ER (2008). Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought. Psychological Bulletin 134(2).
- Grossmann I, Kross E (2014). Exploring Solomon’s paradox. Psychological Science 25(8).